Q. RE: BUILDER IN GOOD OR BAD FAITH
Dear Atty. Rogelio, magandang araw po! Nalaman ko po ang email address mo sa youtube. Nakabili ako ng lupa (rights), 35 sq.meters ang laki, sa Tandang Sora, Quezon City noong 2016. Pinatayuan ko ng bahay (concrete) ang lupa sa parehong taon.
Nagkaproblema ako dito sa MALING SUKAT na sinabi ng asusasyon sa akin, imbes na patatsulok… parihaba ang binigay na sukat. Nasakop ko pala ng bahagya ang katabing bakanteng lote na pagmamay-ari ni letter A na lingid din sa kaalaman ni letter A ang pagsakop. Nalaman na lang namin ang pagsakop noong ibinenta ni letter A ang lote kay letter B ilang buwan ang nakaraan pagkatapos ng bayaran.
Pumapayag ako na gigibain nila ang structure na pumasok sa pag-aari nila pero ang gusto naman ni letter B ay ako ang gagastos or ako mismo ang maggigiba. Medyo pahirapan na rin kami pinansyal simula ng pandemya.
Ito po ang itatanong ko, Atty.: Makatarungan po ba na HINDI ako ang maggigiba o gagastos ng paggiba sa lumagpas sa lote nila?
Ang rason ko kasi, nabili ni letter B ang lupa sa taong 2018 at naipatayo ko ang building taong 2016. Kumbaga nandoon na ang structure nung binayaran ni letter B ang lupa. Ako po ay umaasa na bigyan ng linaw ang katanungan ko. Marami pong salamat. Sincerely yours, KDA/
ANS: Ang question sa usapin mo ay kung sino sa inyo ng Letter B ang maituturing na builder and buyer in good at bad faith. In the case of the Heirs of Durano v. Spouses Uy, the Supreme court ruled the remedies available to the landowner:
The Civil Code provides:
Art. 449. He who builds, plants or sows in bad faith on the land of another, loses what is built, planted or sown without right of indemnity.
Art. 450. The owner of the land on which anything has been built, planted or sown in bad faith may demand the demolition of the work, or that the planting or sowing be removed, in order to replace things in their former condition at the expense of the person who built, planted or sowed; or he may compel the builder or planter to pay the price of the land, and the sower the proper rent.
Art. 451. In the cases of the two preceding articles, the landowner is entitled to damages from the builder, planter or sower. xxx
Based on, these provisions, the owner of the land has three alternative rights: (1) to appropriate what has been built without any obligation to pay indemnity therefor, or (2) to demand that the builder remove what he had built, or (3) to compel the-builder to pay the value of the land. In any case, the landowner is entitled to damages under Article 451.
My view taking into consideration the existing jurisprudence, the builder is presumed in bad faith, if one fails to exercise the required due diligence like a good father of a family in ascertaining that the land where the construction was made actually belongs to the builder.
The required due diligence includes, among others having the land surveyed based on official records or documents of ownership of the builder of his land. Hence, having just to completely rely on a mere say so of somebody in the association without having the statement validated fall short of the benchmark of the required due diligence.
Xxxx xxx
Learning is empowerment. For more information follow the Batas Pinoy Global in the YouTube.com Batas Pinoy Channel. kindly click the subscribed, share, like buttons and tap the notification bell, for future video updates.
Disclaimer: Batas Pinoy Global Community(BPGC). Not Legal opinion:
Material placed on this corner is for the purpose of providing information only. Any communication from this corner does not create lawyer-client relationship of whatever nature and for whatever purpose. It is not intended as practice of law or legal services. Although the writer believes this information to be accurate at the time it is first provided or as relayed by the person asking or soliciting the information from the writer.
Such circumstances or understanding of the facts as conveyed to the writer by the sender may not actually reflect the ultimate facts or circumstances earlier represented and as understood by the writer.
This writer makes no representation, express or implied, as to the accuracy, completeness or timeliness of the information provided in this writing. The contents provided by Batas Pinoy Global Community(BPGC) are not meant as substitute for legal opinion. Always consult your lawyer or other legal professionals for legal advice as regards the emailed or forwarded queries and the corresponding information furnished or as viewed by BPGC.
Readers who may have legal concerns affecting their persons, property, rights, title and related interest concerning Philippine laws and jurisdiction, are welcome to e-mail their query either in English or Pilipino in plain, concise and orderly presentation of facts, (as no follow-up or clarification of queries will be entertained to give way to others in the queue ) in order to avoid vagueness and mis-appreciation of the facts of your stories. For appropriate information write to: attyrw@gmail.com .
WARNING: This communication is intended for use by the individual(s) to whom it is specifically addressed and should not be read by, or delivered to, any other person. Such communication may contain privileged or confidential information. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender and delete this e-mail message immediately. Thank you for your cooperation. * * *