Heir not cooperating in the Settlement of Estate

By | March 12, 2021

Laws relating to family rights and duties,or to  

the status, condition and legal capacity of  

persons are binding upon Filipino citizens, even  

though living abroad.” (Article 15 Civil Code of  

the Philippines)

Heir not cooperating in the 

Settlement of Estate 

Q. Ako po ay taga subaybay ng inyong youtube. On our way na po kami sa processing  sa estate tax. Bale need na lang po namin ang TIN ng isang tagapagmana para po  mabayaran na sana namin ang Estate Tax. Ang problema ayaw po makipag cooperate like  hindi po niya binibigay ang kanyang TIN.  

Pwede po ba macheck sa BIR to update her TIN number. Kaso ang problema po ayaw din  po nya mag issue ng SPA para po ma update namin sa BIR ang kanya pong TIN. Ayaw  nya po makipah cooperate dahil po sa may galit siya o anuman. So pano o ano po  maganda namin para maka secure po kami ng TIN nya from BIR mismo po. Isa na lng po  kulang out of 11 heirs. Salamat po! 

Kind regards. Ms.AB 

ANS: Ung situation mo ay kadalasang nang yayari pag nagkakaroon ng hindi maayos  na relation ang mga heirs hinggil sa settlement of estate ng kanilang ascendants, o  magulang na pumanaw na. Tulad ng nabanggit sa mga usapin sa video, dalawang klase  ang settlement of estate na maaring gawin. Ung pinakaraniwan ay through extrajudicial  settlement, na kung saan ang lahat ng mga heirs a voluntary na agree sa partihan ng mana,  at walang minor, walang utang ang namatay at walang WILL.  

However, pag hindi nagkakasundo at ayaw mag cooperate ung ang alin man sa mga heirs  for whatever reason, ang option sa settlement of estate ay through Judicial Settlement of  Estate and Partition. Sa processing ito, ay mapipilitang makipag ugnayan at lumahok sa  Judicial processes ang mga concerned heirs at kasama na rito ang pag require ng korte sa  kanya na ibigay ang kanyang TIN for tax purposes.Mag kaganoon pa man, you may  confer with the BIR if you can secure the TIN of the concerned heir. 

Ang TIN ng tao, tulad ng ibang mga personal information or data ng isang tao ay  protected ng Data Privacy Act, na kung saan ay hindi basta basta na pilitin ang isang tao  

na ibigay o i-share ang ano mang personal information sa third party ng walang  pahintulot. At assuming na makakuha kayo ng TIN, pero pag ayaw pumirma sa  Extrajudicial Settlement of Estate ang concerned heir, ay hindi rin viable ung  Extrajudicial settlement at maaring mawalan kayo iba pang option but to resort to Judicial  Settlement of Estate with Partition which is adversarial , long and winding process and  more costly and inconvenience on the part the heirs. 

Xxxx xxx 

Learning is empowerment. For more information follow the Batas Pinoy in  the YouTube.com Batas Pinoy Channel. kindly click the subscribed, sharelike buttons and tap the notification bell, for future video updates. 

Disclaimer: Batas Pinoy Global Community(BPGC). Not Legal opinion: 

Material placed on this corner is for the purpose of providing information only. Any communication from this  corner does not create lawyer-client relationship of whatever nature and for whatever purpose. It is not  intended as practice of law or legal services. Although the writer believes this information to be accurate at  the time it is first provided or as relayed by the person asking or soliciting the information from the writer. 

Such circumstances or understanding of the facts as conveyed to the writer by the sender may not actually reflect the ultimate facts or circumstances earlier represented and as understood by the writer. 

 This writer makes no representation, express or implied, as to the accuracy, completeness or timeliness of  the information provided in this writing. The contents provided by Batas Pinoy Global Community(BPGC) are not meant as substitute for legal opinion. Always consult your lawyer or other legal professionals for legal advice as regards the emailed or forwarded queries and the corresponding information furnished or as  viewed by BPGC.  

Readers who may have legal concerns affecting their persons, property, rights, title and related interest  concerning Philippine laws and jurisdiction, are welcome to e-mail their query either in English or Pilipino  in plain, concise and orderly presentation of facts, (as no follow-up or clarification of queries will be  entertained to give way to others in the queue ) in order to avoid vagueness and mis-appreciation of the  facts of your stories. For appropriate information write to: attyrw@gmail.com .  

WARNING: This communication is intended for use by the individual(s) to whom it is specifically  addressed and should not be read by, or delivered to, any other person. Such communication may contain  privileged or confidential information. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the  sender and delete this e-mail message immediately. Thank you for your cooperation.  * * *